“None of these” is plural


Grammarians, grammar geeks, linguists, and editors need a little excitement now and then. We need something to fight about. After all, we’re preserving the civilized world by helping people understand one another, right? A good argument keeps our pencils sharpened and our brains active.

One favorite topic about which we fight is the use of the word “none.” Specifically, is it singular or plural? Does it require a singular or plural verb?

Which of these is correct?
“None of the students is absent.”
“None of the students are absent.”

You might have a preference based on what sounds most familiar to you, but that is a risky way to determine what is correct.

The first camp (singular):
Some argue that “none,” which derives from the term “not one,” must be singular always. This would make the first sentence correct. After all, the subject of the sentence is “none,” followed by the prepositional phrase “of the students.” “Students” is the object of the preposition “of.” Because “none,” meaning “not one,” is the subject, then we need the singular verb “is.”

The second camp (either):
Others argue that “none” is singular or plural depending on what it refers to. For example, in the two above sentences, “none” refers to “students.” We call “students” the referent. Because “none” refers to a plural noun, it is plural, and we need the plural verb “are.” This is similar to finding the antecedent of a pronoun. The pronoun must be singular or plural depending on the word to which it refers.

My side of this argument:
I’m a recent convert to the second camp. I made the switch because 1) this argument makes sense, and 2) “none” has been used this way for centuries.

On some issues, such as “which” vs. “that,” I am a prescriptive grammarian. Regardless of how people (mis)use these words, I stick to the rule. The difference between “that” and “which” is an issue of understanding. These two words communicate different meanings.

On this issue, however, I believe I can safely follow usage patterns and not the “rules.” It doesn’t affect the meaning, which is my most important concern. With this in mind, here’s my advice.

1. Find the word/words to which “none” refers, i.e., the referent.
2. Determine if the referent is singular or plural.
3. Use a singular or plural verb depending on the referent.

Try these:
A. “None of the furniture is/are clean.”
B. “He discovered that none of the drivers know/knows the direction.”
C. “Have you seen my socks? None is/are where I put it/them.”
D. “None sparkle/sparkles.”

Answers:
A. is [The referent is “furniture,” which is singular.]
B. know [The referent is “drivers,” which is plural.]
C. are, them [The referent for “none” and the antecedent for “them” is socks, which is plural.]
D. unknown. [We need the referent to answer this one. For example, if we’re writing about jewelry, we need the singular “sparkles.” If we’re writing about diamonds, we need the plural “sparkle.”]


Free E-book to Improve Your Writing Skills

Writing strategies and instruction from
Precise Edit’s writing guides

  • 1 critical article from
    Precise Edit Training Manual
  • 8 days of instruction from
    300 Days of Better Writing
  • 5 top strategies from
    Bang! Writing with Impact
  • 2 essential word choices from
    Which Word Do I Use?
  • 1 major comma use from Zen Comma
  • 1 powerful chapter about main verbs from Concise Guide to Technical and Academic Writing
WritingCompanionCover

Get the free e-book (PDF) OR
Purchase the Kindle version ($0.99).

Advertisements

3 Comments

Filed under Authors, Businesses, Editing, Mechanics, Writing

3 responses to ““None of these” is plural

  1. Stop

    Thanks for clearing this up

  2. Nicely done. I’m tired of the ‘none is always singular’ camp.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s